Tuesday, May 17, 2011

The Fourth Sunday of Easter

May 15, 2011
The Rev. John A. Baldwin

One of the distinguishing features of the Gospel of John is Jesus' description of himself in "I am" statements: "I am the Vine", "I am the way, the truth & the life", "I am Living Water", "I am the Good Shepherd", "I am the Bread of Life", and from this morning's Gospel, "I am the door of the sheep...if anyone enters by me, he will be saved and will go in and out and find pasture."

Jesus liked to use sheep as illustrations in his stories and parables. He spoke about the importance of seeking out the lost lamb. As the disciples were setting out on a missionary journey, Jesus said to them, "I am sending you out like sheep among wolves." When challenged by the Pharisees about healing on the Sabbath, Jesus replied, "Suppose you had a sheep which fell in a ditch on the Sabbath; is there not one of you who would not catch hold of it and lift it out?"

Having spent nearly 5 months on 3 separate occasions in rural Dorset, England where sheep outnumber residents by a considerable number, I have seen a lot of sheep up close. There is hardly a more peaceable creature. Who has ever been hurt or threatened by a sheep? Yet I've also been told that sheep are not highly intelligent or discerning. If allowed to, they will wander aimlessly seeking pasture. That's why you will never find sheep in England without a fence to keep them in. They are also defenseless against predators. A wolf can find mighty easy pickings in a sheep pasture.

Using sheep as an image or metaphor for human beings is not particularly flattering, but it does point towards some characteristics of human nature that were evident to Jesus: our need for a shepherd to guide and protect us; our tendencies to wander aimlessly through life, without greater purpose at times than keeping our bellies full; and our vulnerabilities to getting lost or being devoured by wolves.

What strikes me about this image of Jesus as the door of the sheep is that it's a two-way door. The sheep have the freedom to go in and out.....to graze peacefully within the protecting walls of the sheepfold, or to stay without, but at the risk of vulnerability to thieves, robbers and strangers. We might well ask: If God entertained such an unflattering view of human nature, why would he allow us to go in and out of the sheepfold, instead of keeping that door firmly shut, and protecting us from ourselves? The answer, I believe, lies in the wonderful, yet terrible gift of freedom that God has given us.

A short film called The Parable was produced for the 1964 World's Fair. In it, a clown in whiteface becomes a Christ figure. He wanders through a circus grounds acting as a servant, carrying pails of water for an overworked elephant tender, taking the place of another in a dunking tank, and dusting the shoes of spectators in the bigtop. Later in the film he straps himself into a harness, taking the place of a "living puppet" in the top of the circus tent. He becomes an actor in a Punch and Judy type show, his arms and legs manipulated with strings by a master puppeteer down below.

In his servanthood, the clown not only stirs up gratitude from those whose roles he assumes, but also enmity in the hearts of those who resent his interference, the bosses and trainers. When the clown straps himself into the harness, they see it as an opportunity to attack him with baseballs, swords and canes. In effect, they crucify him. The master puppeteer, with a lifeless clown now in harness, conducts a macabre dance, moving his limbs in a mockery of life.

This image of the master puppeteer lies close to the heart of what many conceptualize when they think about God. Isn't this what is implicitly meant when people attribute close calls to God's will and plan? For example...the telephone rang as I was going out the door and as a result, I missed by a minute being involved in a fatal accident on I-64. God pulled the string. My friend, my parent, my neighbor has cancer, broke a leg, lost their job (fill in the blanks). It's all part of the plan of the master puppeteer, isn't it? Wars, floods, tornadoes and tsunamis? All part of God's plan. Don't you wonder why some unfortunate people become victims, and others are spared? If God is pulling all the strings, his ways are mysterious and impossible to fathom for sure, but everything happens for a reason, right?

The great theological problem if we ascribe to a view of God as a puppeteer, rescuing some and ignoring others, is that it poses a universe where there is no freedom to choose. We are not free to decide whether to go in or out of the door of the sheepfold. In fact, our decisions really don't matter at all. God will do what God wants to do. We really are like those living puppets, and the dead clown.....helpless participants in a macabre dance of life and death. This seems to me an image more appropriate to Hell rather than to the Kingdom of God.

Basic Christian theology asserts something quite different. God in the self-emptying act of Creation bestowed upon human beings the wonderful yet terrible gift of freedom. We are free to choose between responding to our own needs, wants and desires, or to minister to those of others; to be self-centered, or God-centered; to embrace abundant living, or to nurture those temptations that draw us away from the love of God. Precisely because God values his creation so much, he allows us the freedom to make choices that are foolish even as God fervently hopes we will choose what is loving and good.

In that freedom of choice there is room for error and accident. I can choose to buy a house on an earthquake fault line; to take into my body substances that are harmful to my health; to choose friends whose morals are questionable; to value the outward and material over the inward and spiritual. That's the terrible side of freedom, leading us perhaps to long for a God who pulls strings and saves us from ourselves.

The wonderful side of freedom, however, is that God desires a relationship with us which is truly respectful, allowing us the capability to blunder and then seek reconciliation; to grow in wisdom and strength; to become a new creation; to seek God so as to find Him.

This freedom to choose lies at the heart of our baptismal covenant. Will you continue in the apostles' teaching and fellowship, in the breaking of bread and in the prayers? Will you persevere in resisting evil and whenever you sin, repent and return to the Lord? Will you proclaim by word and example the Good News of God in Christ? Will you seek and serve Christ in all persons, loving your neighbor as yourself? Will you strive for justice and peace among all people and respect the dignity of every human being?

God forces no one to do any of this, but when we do embrace the baptismal covenant, the door to abundant living in this life and the next is open to all who choose to enter.

Monday, May 2, 2011

The Stewardship of Creation Sunday

John A. Baldwin
The Second Sunday after Easter
May 1, 2011   

I came into the office this past week to find our parish administrator in some distress. The mother eagle in the Norfolk Botanical Garden had been hit by a jet and killed. Donna had been following the birth of the baby eaglets and their mother's nurturing of them for several weeks, thanks to a video link to the internet. What had once been the purview of only avid birdwatchers with binoculars had been brought into the living rooms of Tidewater Virginia, and fascination and compassion had ensued. Not only Donna, but many others who'd been engaged with this extraordinary glimpse of nature, found that they cared about a bird, and the drama of her raising her young.

Imagine that, feeling grief about the death of a raptor (a bird of prey) ! But eagles too have little babies whom they nurture and protect. They, like us, are marvels of creation....different from us, but in their own way perfect specimens of nature's creative force at work. When we feel and experience that connection, we begin to care across-species, and I believe we move closer to the heart of God. Last Tuesday night, at our monthly meeting of BUBBLES (theological discussion over a glass of beer at Salvatore's) we considered the question "Do Dogs Go to Heaven?" Sentimentally, of course, everyone affirmed that Spot, Fido and Rover, would definitely go on into life hereafter. After all, dogs display unconditional love in ways that humans often envy. Why wouldn't God draw them closer to his nearer presence? The discussion at our table moved on into reflection upon whether animals have souls, as we believe humans do, and just what is the reality of heaven? Speculative theology, utilizing the imagination to reflect on matters of faith and religion, always enlivens and fascinates me.

What passages in the Bible say about many things is open to speculative theology because scripture utilizes rich imagery, story, human insight, and historical experience to address issues of ultimate importance. It speaks in new and different ways to every generation, and to every sort and condition of human beings. We look at scripture from different vantage points, and in every reading of it we see and hear it through the filters of our personal experience. Consider for example, what is perhaps the most quoted passage in scripture (John 3:16). "God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten son, that whosoever believeth in him will have eternal life." We get so focused on the latter part of this quote, that we glide right over the first 5 words. "God so loved "the world" ......It's not God so loved "humanity", but God so loved "the world"....all of it. Humans come dangerously close to sheer pride and arrogance when we forget to recognize that God created all things, and in the first chapter of Genesis, God blessed all of it as "good"....dogs, cats, and eaglets; earth, winds and waters; mountains, rivers and seas, and maybe even mosquitoes, ticks and chiggers (though some have asserted, tongue in cheek, that those had to be the works of the devil!)

The two stories of creation in Genesis One (the creation of the world in 7 days) and Genesis Two (the story of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden), have important things to say to us this morning as we celebrate the 41st annual Earth Day (albeit a few days late, since this year it fell on Good Friday). Genesis One speaks to our role as participants, allies and co-creators with God in the ongoing work of creation. But it also has those interesting and challenging words within it: "be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth and subdue it". We have been inclined to use the word "subdue" in the modern era primarily as license to conquer, control, own, deplete and use up. But it has a softer side as well, namely to bring into cultivation, reduce the intensity of, tone down. In other words, "to bring into balance." And that is precisely what we see in the beginning of Genesis Two, the Garden of Eden - humans living in harmony with flora and fauna. Trouble sets in, however, as Adam and Eve (who represent all of humanity) decide to seek divinity, to squeeze God out of the picture in the ongoing drama of creation, and go it alone. Adam and Eve fall from grace, not because they are inherently wicked, but because they succumb to pride and hubris. They disrupt the balance within the garden.

Earth Day has evolved over the past 40 years from dire predictions of doom in 1970 to involving citizens from all walks of life into pursuing the goal of a Billion Acts of Green. Back in 1970, dramatic events such as the Cuyahoga River bursting into flame in 1969, the blowout of an oil well off Santa Barbara, and the "death" of Lake Erie due to pollution all fed Americans' concerns. Earth Day 1970 provoked a torrent of apocalyptic predictions. "We have about five more years at the outside to do something," ecologist Kenneth Watt declared to a Swarthmore College audience. Harvard biologist George Wald estimated that "civilization will end within 15 or 30 years unless immediate action is taken against problems facing mankind." "We are in an environmental crisis which threatens the survival of this nation, and of the world as a suitable place of human habitation," wrote Washington University biologist Barry Commoner.

Imminent global famine caused by the explosion of the "population bomb" was the big issue on Earth Day 1970. "Population will inevitably and completely outstrip whatever small increases in food supplies we make," Paul Ehrlich confidently declared in an interview. "The death rate will increase until at least 100-200 million people per year will be starving to death during the next 10 years." Pollution was another big issue on Earth Day 1970. Smog choked many American cities and sludge coated the banks of many rivers. People were also worried that we were poisoning the biosphere and ourselves with dangerous pesticides. The Great Lakes were in bad shape and Lake Erie was officially "dead," its fish killed because oxygen supplies had been depleted by rotting algae blooms fed by organic pollutants from factories and municipal sewage. Beyond anxiety over population, pollution, and pesticides, even more long-term concerns were on display at the first Earth Day, including the depletion of nonrenewable resources, disappearing biodiversity, and global climate change due to human activity--all of which have come to figure prominently in our current environmental debates.

Fortunately, the apocalyptic gloom and doom of Earth Day 1970, while waking a lot of people up, didn't prove as prophetic as we might have feared at the time. While, it's absolutely true that far too many people remain poor and hungry in the world--800 million people are still malnourished--we have not seen mass starvation around the world in the past four decades. Where there have been famines, such as in Somalia and Ethiopia, they have been primarily the result of war and political instability. Far from turning brown, the Green Revolution has made a huge difference in food production outpacing population growth. According to the World Bank's World Development Report 2000, food production increased by 60 percent between 1980 and 1997. What about the fears expressed about the world's population? In 2000 there were 6 billion - 30% fewer than predicted on Earth Day 1970, because total fertility dropped nearly everywhere on the planet from around 6 children per woman in the 1960s to around 2.8 in 2000. In the U.S., air quality has improved significantly over the past 40 years, and similar trends can be found when it comes to water pollution. Lake Erie once "dead" again supports a $600 million fishing industry. 

Earth Day 2011 is much less apocalyptic in nature, much less filled with gloom and doom, yet none the less deeply serious in encouraging each of us to become involved in restoring the balance in nature. In an effort dubbed "A Billion Acts of Green," organizers are encouraging people to pledge online at actearthday.com. to do something small but sustainable in their own lives to improve the planet's health — from switching to compact fluorescent light bulbs to reducing the use of pesticides and other toxic chemicals. "Millions of people doing small, individual acts can add up to real change," said a spokesman for the group coordinating efforts. There were hundreds of rallies, workshops and other events around the United States and hundreds more overseas where it is now celebrated in 192 countries. In the years since the first Earth Day was celebrated in 1970 the environmentalist movement has made great strides with passage of the Clean Air and Clean Water Acts, the Endangered Species Act and other groundbreaking laws. Sadly, the bipartisanship that marked the birth of Earth Day — it was sponsored in Congress by Wisconsin Democrat Gaylord Nelson and California Republican Pete McCloskey — is too often missing in discussions about environmental policy today.

My own theological perspective is marked more by optimism than pessimism. I am a firm believer that God is actively involved in all that is going on in the cosmos, and that God earnestly desires for us to be in partnership with Him in the ongoing work of Creation. I believe that the Earth Day movement is moving in a positive direction in evolving from apocalyptic gloom and doom to encouraging each one of us to do our small part in personal initiatives. We have been very fortunate at Emmanuel to have a small but very dedicated Green Team looking faithfully at how we here in Virginia Beach can make a contribution. I invite you to join them in this effort as faithful members of Christ's family, the Church.

~~~
In the name of God: Creator, Redeemer, and Sustainer.

Easter 2011 Sermon

John A. Baldwin

Easter 2011

Journalist and author Hunter Thompson once said,  "Life should not be a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in a pretty and well preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside in a cloud of smoke, thoroughly used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming "Wow! What a Ride!"
I love this quote, because I believe it is a brave, bold and audacious affirmation of love for life, and faith in what lies beyond it. Those who hesitate, equivocate, hold back, or live cautiously and timidly will miss much of life's zest and adventure. Those who live their lives in fear and trembling, will likewise approach their death with dread and terror. Do we not envy at some level those who die pursuing their passion, be it on the golf course, on the rock face of a mountain, or on the journey of a lifetime, while we inwardly feel so very sad for those who never follow their hearts.
One thing that may be said about Jesus of Nazareth is that on the cross Jesus died, thoroughly used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming, "It is finished!" He expended every ounce of his being, loved lavishly, gave with abandon, and never looked back with regret on anything he said or did in pursuing the Kingdom of Heaven. The portrait the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John paint of Jesus, is that of a man who experienced the heights and depths of human living to their very fullest extent.
When Jesus' body was taken down from the cross and placed in the tomb, it was not a pretty sight. It was beaten and bruised all over, covered with blood, a pitiful sight from which all but the hard-hearted would avert their eyes. It should come as no surprise that Mary Magdalene, in the early morning hours near the tomb, did not recognize Jesus. She still had vividly in her mind's eye the broken body of Jesus on the cross, depleted, spent, totally used up. But now, here before her is a strong, robust, and vital human being. Had to be the gardener! Who else would be skulking about in the garden so early in the day. 
In that brief interval between night time on top of Golgotha and dawn on the first day of the week, something mysterious, powerful, awesome had happened to the body of Jesus. It has been infused with Resurrection power, revitalized and restored. Mary's eyes are jolted open by the sound of his voice. She recognizes instantly the man she, and all the other disciples, had come to love and cherish.
In the days that followed, Jesus made numerous appearances to the other disciples, startling them, lifting their spirits to new heights of awe and wonder, and empowering them to devote the rest of their lives to spreading the Good News of Jesus' Resurrection. What made it "Good News" for these men and women was not simply that one man had somehow cheated the Grim Reaper, but that they had experienced up close the renewing power of Resurrection energy. Nothing convinces me more thoroughly of the reality of the Resurrection than the transformation that occurred in the lives of the disciples. They changed from pitiable, terrified, defeated people into bold proclaimers of the Gospel, ultimately traveling to the ends of the earth to share their experiences, many of them dying martyrs' deaths along the way. Their fear of death miraculously seems to have vanished, replaced by a deep and firm faith that in Jesus of Nazareth, the divine has come to dwell among us, and life will forever be very, very different.
I see at work in Peter, Paul, and many others of faith down through the centuries, very little interest in arriving safely at death in a pretty and well preserved body. Rather they are engaged in skidding in broadside in a cloud of smoke, thoroughly used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming "Wow! What a Ride!" Is this not faith at work? ........emboldened by a deep-seated belief in the reality and power of the Resurrection......not just for one man, way back when, but for all who love God with passion.
What does this suggest to us across the centuries? How should we be expending our energy in our journey from birth to the grave, and beyond? If we only have one life to live, what a shame to live it in fear and timidity! What a waste not to fully use our gifts and talents to create things of beauty! What sadness not to share generously with others the spark of the divine within our hearts and souls! How tragic, if as we end our days, we look back over our life and say, I wish I hadn't spent the majority of it on things that really don't matter to me at all.
Let's look again Jesus Christ who, I believe, displays for us what living a vital, authentic human life is all about. In Jesus, we see no self-centered, narcissistic, selfishness at all. He lavishly poured out his love on others from little children.....to sinners, prostitutes and tax-collectors... to lepers, epileptics, and the demon-possessed......even to his enemies from the cross. Even his criticism of the scribes and Pharisees, which may sound harsh to us from a long distance removed in time, was intended I believe to redirect their zealous piety away from rules and regulations to matters of the heart, and therefore did not come out of anger or malice, but out of a deep concern for their lives and souls.
Jesus didn't waste his time on things that were trivial and unimportant. He expended his energy on waking people up to what is essential in living life to its fullest. His Sermon on the Mount is filled with this wisdom: "Blessed are the merciful"; "Blessed are the peacemakers"; "You are the salt of the earth"; "Lay up for yourselves treasure in heaven"; "You cannot serve God and money"; "Do not be anxious about your life"; "Judge not that you be not judged"; "Ask and it will be given you, seek and you will find". The Sermon on the Mount gathers the nuggets of Jesus' teaching together and we see revealed within it the wisdom of a man closely in synch with the heart of God.
There is no better way of judging, I believe, whether how we are expending our time, talent and energy is fruitful, authentic and life-giving than to ask ourselves, what would Jesus do? Would he be harboring resentment and anger towards others? Would he be giving himself negative messages about his gifts and abilities? Would he be allowing fear and anxiety to get the upper hand?
When I die, I too want to be able to say "Wow, what a ride" ......But not because I've plumbed the ocean depths in scuba gear, bungi-jumped off a tall bridge, made a hole in one, or been to the uttermost parts of the Earth...thrilling as all that might be. Rather I'd like to be able to say "What a Ride" because I've loved deeply; because I've been fully present and involved in significant moments in the lives of those I care about; because I've courageously expressed wisdom I've received through the years; because I've not held back from making a difference in the world around me.
How about you? What do you need to do, or be, in order to be able to shout out with joy, "Wow, what a ride" when God calls you home?

Good Friday

The Rev. Julia W. Messer
4/22/2011
Good Friday-- Year A-RCL
John 18:1-19:42

GOOD FRIDAY
            Condemned by the crowd, with sneers and taunts being thrown at him, Jesus picked up his cross, made his way through the crowd, and headed to Golgotha. Crowds had surrounded Jesus throughout his ministry.  At one time, those crowds had reached out to touch him so that they might be healed. Crowds had gathered because they wanted to hear his words. Crowds who, just a few days earlier, had shouted “Hosanna in the highest” were now shouting “Crucify him!” 
            How quickly the tide turned. It started just hours earlier, with betrayals from those closest to Jesus.  First it was Judas, one of the disciples, one of his own, who turned against him and abandoned Jesus to the anger and fear of those who sought to silence this man called Jesus of Nazareth. Then before the cock crowed to signal the dawn of the day that Jesus would be crucified on, another disciple, Peter, forsook Jesus and denied him three times.
            Jesus, condemned by those closest to him, seemed abandoned and alone, standing there in a crowd. When he looked closer he did see those who had not betrayed him, but they couldn’t step forward on his behalf because they were either powerless or too afraid of the powers “that be”.  Betrayed and in pain, Jesus lifted the heavy and cold wood of the cross onto his back and took his first steps to Calvary. 
            It was in these moments, that Jesus, God’s only son, showed the world what it meant to be human, and to be obedient to God, no matter what the cost. Bleeding and betrayed, Jesus walked through the crowds on the road to Golgotha but his human body had trouble sustaining the weight of the burden he had been asked to bear.           
There are times in our lives that the cross we bear is our own frailty. We too can be borne down by pains. When cancer or sickness attacks the body, or when the body starts to age and is unable to do what it used to do, we may have trouble sustaining the weight. Financially, even psychologically, the weight of our sorrows and the loss of control start to weigh down not only our bodies, but also our souls.  But as Christ taught us here on this road, that despite the weight of this cross, he kept going as best as he could.
It is here as Christians that we are shown what it means to have true reverence for what we have. For true reverence begins as a deep understanding of our human limitations; from this grows the capacity to be in awe of whatever we believe lies outside our control—God, truth, justice, nature, and even death. The capacity for awe, as it grows, brings with it the capacity for respecting fellow human beings, flaws and all. In this, we are offered a chance to see and to learn to accept the weakness in others, just as we must learn to accept them in ourselves. We too must continue on our path, just as Jesus did.
             Jesus continued on the way, surrounded by crowds who had turned against him, whose hatred was thrown in the face of the weakening Jesus, yet interspersed in the crowd, Jesus caught glimpses of those who loved him, yet were powerless to help him.  In times of deep darkness, to catch a glimpse of grace, or to see a loved one who has not abandoned us can be uplifting, but it can also be bitter sweet. They are moments of grace and joy because of the joy in knowing that we are not forsaken in times of despair. Yet they are also heart-wrenching when we realize that the road we are on or a loved one is on is causing such deep pain and mourning for loved ones.  To see it reflected back in their eyes can be hard to bear.  To know that we are the ones causing the pain to those who unconditionally love us is a cross to bear.
            We can’t deny the intensity of human pain. The intensity can be made to feel even worse when we are isolated from our friends and family.  When we are in our pain, we may not feel that God is not listening to us. But with every fiber of our being, we are God’s, and therefore we are NEVER abandoned; we are NEVER without his presence, even if we question it at times.  Jesus was not alone when he suffered and neither are we.  As we bear our crosses, God is always with us, yoked beside us every step of the way. Never abandoned, never alone, we are called to walk every day of our lives with Christ.  And when we die, we die with Christ and are raised into eternal life with him, through this costly grace.  
            Since the dawn of time, people have suffered. God’s people do suffer at the hands of evil, and even do cause evil themselves-- however intentional or not. We suffer pain, we suffer defeat. However we are called by Jesus, who suffered more than we can ever imagine, to learn true obedience to God. We learn to keep going, no matter what the outcome-- just as Jesus did, along his way through the winding paths that lead him to Golgotha.  He never turned back; he kept going so that he could do the will of God.          
We are called to find moments of grace in the suffering, knowing that we never suffer alone.  On some roads, the journey seems to end in moments of utter despair, where the darkest hours stretch on indefinitely, but yet still, we are never alone. God’s promises are like the stars in heaven that shine the brightest against the darkness of night, the brightest light is the Son of Man. And with all my heart and soul, I know that, that even “though my soul may sit in darkness, it will rise in perfect light, [because] I have loved the stars too fondly to be fearful of the night.” (paraphrased quote from Sarah Williams) 

We each go through our own Good Friday, sometimes multiples of them. We each bear our own crosses in each of our darkest hours, yet we do not bear them alone.  God is with us.  Sometimes it takes being in that place for us to realize this and know it in our souls.
            Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a Christian leader in Germany during the time that Hitler’s Third Reich was committing atrocities, was willing to stand out from the crowd and to follow Christ. He said, as he was being held captive in a concentration camp, “When Christ calls as man, he bids him—come and die.”
            When God called His Son, our Savior, he called Jesus to do what Jesus now calls us to do. That is, in full obedience to God, to pick up our crosses, and follow him.
~~~
In the name of God: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

Monday, April 11, 2011

5th Sunday of Lent Sermon

April 10, 2011
Fifth Sunday of Lent –A
 The Rev. Marguerite Alley

If only….I had not stayed up so late
If only I hadn’t gone to bed so early, I wouldn’t have missed

If only I had stayed with that diet
If only I had allowed myself a few pleasures from time to time

If only I hadn’t let myself get so out of shape
If only I hadn’t been so driven

If only I had taken that job
If only I hadn’t taken that job

If only I had waited
If only I had gone sooner

If only I had thought longer about it
If only I had gone with my gut

If only I had known
If only you had known

I think most of us have spent our lives re-visiting past decisions and circumstances, re-imagining how the outcome might be different had we decided differently, or how we could have made a better decision if we had more information, or a better sense of timing.
We spend our lives saying “if only”. If and only are two of the smallest, and yet most meaningful words in our language. “If” is full of hope and possiblility. It is full of imagination. It has no limits. If ______ then.   But “only”. The word “only” is limiting. It implies a smaller portion. I suggests less. It is lonely. Put the two words together and you have a conundrum. Change the order of the two and you get a slightly different twist. “Only if” suggests there is some hope. “Only if” says that under these specific  circumstances this will happen. But “If only” suggests something has been lost; something didn’t happen; something won’t or can’t happen.

Mary and Martha were close and dear friends of Jesus, as was their brother Lazarus. I recently read a fascinating commentary that suggested and presented some rather compelling evidence that Lazarus was “the disciple whom Jesus loved”, and that because Jesus raised him from death, he and Jesus shared a very unique and close bond that none of the other disciples would have been able to understand. But, that’s a lesson for another day!
Six days before Jesus goes to Jerusalem for the last time he spends more time with Lazarus and his sisters. Clearly, the sisters felt confortable enough with him to just let it rip when he finally shows up at their door. Try to put yourself for a moment in their shoes. Your close friend has an amazing gift for healing. Because you are good friends, he has pledged to always be there for you. So when your beloved brother is taken suddenly and dangerously ill, the first and best thing you can think of is to call your friend. You are immediately a little relieved. You have done something to make the situation a bit less scary, and help is on the way. But your brother dies anyway because your friend never shows up. You have the funeral. You are at home afterward grieving, trying to figure out what to do next. Your grieving is not just about the loss of your loved one though. You are also angry and grieving that your so- called best friend never showed up. He didn’t even care enough to come and try to save your brother. Now…4 days after you called, the day after the funeral, there is your friend standing in the driveway. It is little wonder that Martha dispenses with the usual formalities of greeting familiars and cuts right to the chase when she says very directly: “If only you had been here, this would not have happened”.
Every decision made for us and that we make for ourselves…from the day we are born shapes who we will become. “If only” doesn’t really matter because even if we could have a “do over”, we can never get back to the exact moment in time, in the exact place, with all the same considerations and make a different decision. We are where we are, because this is where we are supposed to be. We are who we are, because this is who we are supposed to be.

I could say that perhaps the lesson we gain from this story is that we should not fear death. But it is human nature to be afraid of the unknown. Since God made us humans, I think it safe to assume that human emotions are expected. I could say it is meant to make us believe in miracles. But there are plenty of miracles everyday that could do that. Ecosystems are miracles. Babies are miracles.  Medicine is a miracle.  The Red Sox winning the World Series was a miracle. There is no shortage of miracles to make us believe. I could say that the point of the story is to say that if you believe in Jesus, everything will be OK. Your loved one won’t die. But we know that is just not true. All of us I suspect have grieved at the death of someone we knew and loved or at least understand on some level that the death of the human body is a natural and expected occurrence. So maybe…we have to look a bit deeper to get what the real point of this story might be.

Maybe this story is about timing. Our sense of timing guides us…and when things don’t happen the way we think they should or when they should, we shake our fist at God and say “If you had been here”. Think of all the natural disasters that have occurred in the past 10 years. It would be quite easy for someone experiencing any one of those to shake their fist at God and say “if only you had been here”! But  maybe our understanding of time is so limited we can not really grasp God’s sense of time and so we can’t really understand at all why things happen the way they do…both for good or bad. Choosing to believe that things happen randomly is one way to go, but it raises too many obvious questions for me.
Maybe the story is about faith. Martha had absolutely no doubt that things would have been different if Jesus had been there. She never asks Jesus to change the outcome. She just makes a simple statement of faith. “If only you had been here, things would be different now”. We can make that same assertion. If Jesus were here now, things would be mightily different. If Jesus had been here yesterday, they would definitely be different today.
There was another time in Jesus’ ministry when he acted without regard to our concept of time. This was at the wedding of Cana. There, his mother had evidently already figured out that he was not your garden variety 30 yr old man. When she reports to him that the wine had given out, he says “What concern is that to us? My hour has not yet come.” She does not overtly ask him to do anything, just as Martha never says “fix this”.  But I expect that there was at least some understanding on the part of Jesus, that he was in fact expected to do something, whether or not he was ready. His response is  rather extraordinary when compared to what the situation calls for. He could have sent his disciples to get more wine. That would have saved the day as well. But instead he performs a remarkable miracle. Now let’s imagine for a second the whole array of possible miracles available to him. He could have put them into a deep sleep, and when they woke, they would  have no memory of running out of wine. They would remember the wedding and what a lovely time they had. The father of the bride would have been spared embarrassment and the day saved. But was that his goal? He could have taken over the reception, used it as his pulpit and given a lecture about the evils of alcohol. Everyone would have put down their drinks, and the day might have been saved. But was that his goal? You see my point. Here at the beginning of his ministry, he is making a very public statement about who he is and what his role is and will be. You may also note, that he doesn’t seem too happy about the circumstance. He seems in fact a bit cranky that his mother has brought this news to him; perhaps because this is the moment of truth for him. Perhaps this in when he fully understands himself and his relationship with God.
In today’s story he is at the end of his ministry and he mirrors the wedding feast miracle with something even greater. It is important to note that each of these miracles speak to people in a profound way. Each of them involves very human FEARS. The fear of embarrassment or humiliation is over turned when the wine appears from water. At the tomb of Lazarus the very human fear of death and the pain of grief is over turned. So, is the goal of these miracles to save the day? Does Jesus wander about singing that little ditty “Here I come to save the day”? Or is the goal of these amazing miracles something altogether different? I would suggest that his goal is NOT to save the day, not to save us from humiliation and death but rather to declare that we do not need to fear them.
Now I won’t try to convince you that Jesus did this as naturally as we want to believe. I think we would all like to see Jesus as a Superman of sorts. We’d like to think that raising Lazarus was a walk in the park; all in a days work.  But if you read the Gospel very carefully, you will see some very strong language that we don’t often see in the Gospels. The actual translation reads that he was “convulsed within by emotion”. And it says this twice. Clearly, the author is trying to relay something important. If he was just sad at the loss of his friend Lazarus, I don’t think the author would have chosen to tell us this in such strong language. Even when we hear the story of the money changers at the Temple a few days after this, we are only told that Jesus is angry and that he physically turns over the tables of the moneychangers. We are not told that he is crying in his rage, or that he is convulsed with emotion. So clearly we are meant to get something more from this.
So…why do you think Jesus is so emotional? Certainly he knows that he will be able to raise Lazarus. Why is he so upset? I think it is because he suddenly realizes that he will have to face this very thing as well, and it is coming faster and sooner than he wants. So this miracle for Lazarus and his sisters, is also in a sense, Jesus’ own very personal and very human struggle with death. You may or may not know…that the “agony in the garden” does not appear in this gospel. Some scholars have suggested that this is because this scene outside the tomb of Lazarus pretty much says it all.

The only other time Jesus cries in the Gospels is as he is entering Jerusalem for the last time and sees the destruction of the Temple. In this scene, he recognizes without doubt, what will become of him in the next few days. The story from the Gospel we will read next week tells it in great detail so I won’t go there today. But I do want to point out that even Jesus utters the phrase  “if only” as he is riding into Jerusalem. So this very human need to second- guess ourselves or someone else, the need to re-imagine the outcome is present even in the Son of Man. He has been preaching and teaching for 3 years or so and now the time is come for him to be “glorified” and he is shaking with fear. Perhaps for an instant he realizes, as a human, that our preoccupation with time, and God’s creation of time are naturally opposed.

We are bound by our sense of time…just as Lazarus was bound for burial. Jesus unbinds him and gives him life again. Is this just a metaphor or is it real? Does it matter? Is it any less powerful as a metaphor than as an actual occurrence? 

Next Sunday we begin Holy Week. We will re-enact Jesus’ entry into Jerusalem at our Palm Sunday liturgy and hear the first reading of the Passion Story. I would like you to remember some of what we have learned today as we begin that journey. The crowds will be gathered, shouting and cheering, not because we have come on our own to the understanding that Jesus is the Son of God. We will have gathered actually to see Lazarus…the one whom he has raised from death. We have come to see if it is really true. Does he look the same? Is he a ghost? Was he really dead or just asleep? By the end of the day, we will have run away in fear. Despite having seen one who has been raised, and the one who will completely conquer death, we will allow our fear to govern our behavior, our thinking and our hearts. And we will all walk out that door next week and say “if only I had known”.
__________

Monday, April 4, 2011

4 Lenten Meditation

Lenten Reflection Week 4: Loneliness and Solitude
April 3, 2011
The Rev. J.W. Messer
Loneliness and Solitude. Not two words that we, as a society, lift up and praise, but are very important in our faith journey.  Loneliness can be the longing feeling for another in a state of separation. Solitude is when one is placed in a state of separation.  It’s hard not to relate to these feelings at least once in our lives, and it is one way we can connect with the man who had been born blind in today’s Gospel reading.
For me when I am in moments of deep loneliness, such  as when I am grieving the loss of a loved one at a funeral or when I find myself by myself standing on a mountain top in prayer and in solitude, it’s hard for me not to connect with a song that seems to transcend both these moments. When I read today’s Gospel and read these words from the blind man:  “I was blind, now I see.”, it was  pretty hard not to hear the same song “ Amazing Grace” in my head.
"Amazing Grace, how sweet the sound,   
that saved a wretch like me....
I once was lost but now am found,
was blind, but now, I see.
How can grace transcend the pain I was going through at this funeral, or the stillness I was in on the mountain? How can God’s amazing grace transform me from lost to found and blind to seeing? How can we explain this state of mind and feeling when it truly overwhelms us? It is in the same way that we do not know that we are a wretch, lost, or blind until we are touched by grace and realize we are saved, are found, and can now see clearly. Grace is an awe inspiring gift that is hard to explain. Yet in the last three Sunday’s Gospel readings, three different people in different states of being got a new insight of what grace is.
                People like Nicodemus (John 3), the Samaritan Woman at the well (John 4), and the man born blind (John 9) are each examples of inadequate discipleship. It is only once they come to faith that they then want to come to a deeper understanding of God’s grace.  It is trying to understand a new feeling when you are limited in your experience and in vocabulary or experience--It’s like trying to explain the ocean to someone who has never seen it.
                The man born blind was alone in his darkness, and when he was given his sight by Jesus, he still found himself alone. When he was asked by the Pharisees how the miracle happened, he knew the physical act that took place but it was harder to explain what actually happened.  The same applies for us; there are times that unless another person has been in the same boat as us, it’s hard to explain what we are feeling or going through. And each situation and person’s perspective is different. The thing is, when we are before God in our weakened state we are alone in that no matter how much someone loves us or is supporting us; it is always between God and us.  And how we experience grace is a unique experience to each person.  Sometime our moments of experience do come when we are alone, in either our solitude or our loneliness, but it is in those times when we are offered the chance to see when we once before were blind. 

4 Lent 2011

The Rev. Julia W. Messer
4.3.2011 Forth Sunday in Lent-- Year A-RCL
1 Samuel 16:1-13, Psalm 23, Ephesians 5:8-14, John 9:1-41

The man born blind...and Perspective
Children’s Chapel send off story:
Today’s gospel reading is about Jesus healing a blind man and trying to help those around him get a better understanding of who he was. Jesus was trying to offer them a clearer perspective—perspective means a way of seeing things. For example, let’s say you want to have a cookie before dinner. You want the cookie because you’re hungry. The way your mother sees it is that it is too close to dinner and you might not eat all of your dinner if you eat a cookie first. Your brother might see it as unfair because if you ate that cookie you would have more than he does. And the way your dog sees it is that he is hoping you do eat the cookie and the crumbs fall on the ground so he can eat it all up. One cookie, but 4 different ways of seeing it—or as we say, four different perspectives.
So in today’s chapel, be sure to listen to how people see things and how their perspectives are different.
~~~
You may not know this about me, but I love soccer. I’ve been a player, a fan, an assistant coach for a boys JV team, and a soccer referee for over half of my life. And being a referee isn’t easy…you would be surprised at how many people shout at us during a game that we must be blind or deaf. It’s true--how many of us have at some time yelled at a game or even on a TV screen “REF, come on! That was a foul! What are you-- blind?!”
     Sometimes referees just don't see things correctly, even when they are right beside the play. With the gift of instant replay that offers numerous different angles, it might be revealed that the referee actually called the right play. And then again sometimes the refs are watching too much and miss a foul. And let’s face it, as players, as fans, and as coaches, we are horribly biased towards our own team. When we see our team commit a foul, we aren’t going to actually shout out “Hey ref, we’re the ones that fouled!” Referees are there to offer an unbiased perspective which can shed new light on a situation, and they are right there in the mud with the players, meeting them exactly where they are at that moment in time.

     Perspective. It can make a world of difference to us when we change how we see an event or how we respond to it. Whether it is a hidden picture that is suddenly seen or hearing what the other person had to say about a situation, our perspective can suddenly shift when “we get it”.

     I feel the same applies to the readings today as well as the Lenten season in general. The “Lord does not see as mortals see” (1Sam16) and God does not act how we might expect Him to. God didn’t act the way the Israelites thought they would see God’s actions. Jesus did things that people thought he would not—like healing people on a Sabbath after Sabbath, which we hear about again in today’s reading.

     I love the conversation between the once blind man, the Pharisees, and Jesus when Jesus tells them that he will make those who do not see, may see, and those who see, may become blind. Then the Pharisees actually wonder “Are we blind?” Talk about trying to figure out what is and what isn’t!  In this situation Jesus is like a referee, in that he was right there where they were, trying to offer a clearer perspective of God and God’s grace.
                                                         
   When the Pharisees wonder, “Are we blind?”, Jesus tells them that “If you were blind, you would not have sin." But now that you say, ‘We see’ your sin remains.”
Sounds a little confusing, but what Jesus was trying to convey was that if you cannot see what you are doing is sin, then you aren’t in the right perspective to see what is really going on.  If you do not realize your eyes are shut, then how can you know they are opened?
 
   The Pharisees sinned because they knew the word of God -- they knew the loving and forgiving God that revealed Himself to Moses and the other prophets -- yet they could not see they were not showing this love and forgiveness to God’s people. They condemned anyone who followed Jesus, threw them out of the synagogue, and looked down on a blind man and his family because he was born differently from them.

Yet it was because this man was different than the others that he truly got to experience the world. While he had to rely on other’s generosity to help him live, he got to see the world in its fullness-- in its cruelness and its generosity. What the man knew of the world was through the ways he experienced it… through sound, taste, feel, and smell -- this is how he ‘saw’ the world. Yet Jesus went out and found this blind man, and made the first move. Jesus initiated healing for this man, by getting down into the mud then placed it on to the man’s eyes. But the man also had to be willing to go and wash in the water of Siloam (which means being sent). The man had to be willing to be sent in faith that he would be healed. The man first heard Jesus before he saw him, yet that was enough to make this man take the first steps in faith. In the Gospel reading, it doesn’t say how far away the pool was from where he was, nor does it say how many obstacles the man might have run into, but we can infer that he persisted in the hope of being healed.

     Once there, the man was healed and was given a new perspective on life -- one where he could not only see, but also experienced God’s grace first-hand. It only took this one experience for this man to know that he wanted to become a disciple of Christ. And as a follower of Christ, he would still get persecuted--but he already knew what that was like. Life wasn’t magically going to be perfect for him, but he received a gift far greater than physical sight. He was given spiritual sight and could see and he received God’s grace.

     Certainly there are moments in all of our lives when we grapple for God’s guidance and we may feel blind. Previously we might have had spiritual clarity and life seemed bright and clear. Then we may have found ourselves, or find ourselves, struggling to discern God’s voice in the crowd around us. Or we may find ourselves like the Pharisees, who were intelligent people, yet refused to see the miracles that occurred right before their very eyes! A man born blind could see! They couldn’t accept this because Jesus healed on the Sabbath and must therefore be a sinner too. The way they thought God interacted and the way God DID interact, did not fit into their neat little box of how they understood God.

     Yet God calls us to open our eyes to the presence of Him in our lives. God call us to look at our lives from the perspective that He calls us to live each moment with meaning and love. When we hear God’s voice and go where He calls us, we might have our eyes opened to new wonders or God’s grace. Sometimes, God may call us to a place that makes us to roll up our sleeves and get in the mud and grime, and meet others which also let’s God meet us there in the dirt of life.

     We may be blind at times, or think we are unable to truly see what is going on around us, but maybe just maybe, we are in the perfect position and have the perfect perspective to be able to see God’s work in the world.

What I think best describes the formerly blind man’s perspective is best said by theologian, Joni Erickson Tada. She wrote wrote, “Faith isn't the ability to believe long and far into the misty future. It's simply taking God at His Word and taking the next step.”

        +  In the name of God: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.+